John Cochrane has posted an important blog post about adapting to climate change.  His piece mainly focuses on macroeconomic issues.  For decades, John was colleagues with Bob Lucas and those familiar with Robert Lucas's optimistic work on economic growth will see a correlation.  While John makes many points, his main point is;  "if a world's economy grows by 3% per year out to the year 2100 --- it will be rich enough to handle any of Mother Nature's shocks at that point or along the way".   He points to the growth of China's economy as an example.  John is optimistic about our future;

"The share of the world population in extreme poverty is plummeting. No plausible estimate of climate damage comes close to this kind of change.  And this change comes in part from increasing diffusion of fossil fuels. People who used to hoe by hand now use tractors."

John's piece really focuses on misallocation.  He wants nations to remove misallocation road blocks such as land use restrictions to unleash economic growth so that more nations and their citizens have the income to take the steps they deem necessary to handle the harder punches thrown by Mother Nature.  

As a macroeconomist, John views decarbonization as one strategy that raises our real income in the year 2100 and he wants this strategy to be compared to other pro-growth strategies.  Another quote from JC;

"But reducing carbon is thus, logically, just one item on the list of answers to "What can we do to raise GDP in 2100?," and especially "What can we do to raise GDP in currently-poor countries by 2100?" Asked that way, you can see that "lower carbon emissions" is about #100 on the list, even admitting the 5-10% of GDP thumb-on-the-scale estimates. It's like asking whether removing that "Go Bears" flag from your radio antenna will improve your gas mileage and lower your overall expenses. Well, yes, maybe, but it's hardly first on the list." 


My Thoughts;

1.  Take a look at David Sattherthwaite's 2010 tough review of my 2010 Climatopolis book.  You will see that John and I share many thoughts in common on this topic.  I have working on the costs of climate change for 15 years now going back to my 2005 Death Toll paper.    Once I estimated that richer nations suffer fewer deaths per-capita in natural disasters , I immediately saw the implications for climate change adaptation.  Robert Lucas hadn't connected his economic growth work to a nation's non-market quality of life. He was implicitly assuming that there are complete markets and was not incorporating ideas from his buddy Sherwin Rosen on non-market quality of life.  

2.   John does not discuss rare disasters at fat tail risk.  Martin Weitzman's key research was really about macro-economics.  Marty argued that rising global GHG emissions pose new ambiguous risks for economy.  Such fat tails could be quite disruptive if there are supply chain networks to the economy (intuitively think of a domino chain).  While I greatly respect Marty's work, here is my response.   Marty was my friend and we would debate.  I am a microeconomist and I said to Marty; "Many of us know that we do not know what risks climate change will pose.  Those of us who are risk averse will seek out implicit insurance schemes and those that feature option value so that we can move ourselves and our capital to "higher ground" (i.e safer places) if climate change turns out to be as bad as you claim.  Firms can build in redundancies in supply chains and use hedging markets to reduce their risk exposure. " 

Weitzman's great work didn't engage with Townsend's work on risk sharing and Ehrlich and Becker's work on self protection. Climate change represents a set of spatial shocks and we can always re-optimize as we learn.  This is a key theme of my Climatopolis book and my 2021 Yale University Press book Adapting to Climate Change.

3.  John sets society's goal as maximizing per-capita income in the year 2100.  Would Greta agree with him?  The answer hinges on whether there are complete markets. If there are complete markets then the separation theorems hold.  With complete markets, the loss we suffer in terms of lost natural capital would be subtracted from GNP to calculate per-capita income net of depreciation to natural capital.   If there are incomplete markets, then one must be more explicit about whether the loss of natural capital imposes losses on us that $ can't offset.  An example. The recent heat wave may have killed a billion creatures.    Is this loss of natural capital reflected in market prices?  Yes, if these are market commodities.

4.  John's blog post doesn't sketch out any Gary Becker household production functions, what does extra $ in 2100 buy us in terms of safety, comfort or health or protection of our children?  This is a key theme of my 2021 book.  John's optimism (that I share) hinges on knowing that money will buy inputs that can offset Mother Nature's stronger punches caused by climate change.  The Beatles sang that "money can't buy me love".  IO economists continue to try to estimate structural production functions of making goods. What do we know about structural production functions of producing health and safety?   How do these production functions of Beckerian goods change over time due to new information and new goods?   At a conference in 2019 that honored Frank Wolak, I presented these slides to make these points clear.  

5.  John does not discuss the feedback loop.  If economic growth accelerates, then GHG emissions will accelerate (given current technologies).   See the paper by Davis and Gertler in PNAS 2015 for an example.  John would counter that per-capita income growth will accelerate decarbonization as the Paul Romer green innovation effect will kick in so that Universities such as Uchicago and Stanford do more basic research and this leads more Elon Musks in the future to launch more green firms selling great green products that richer people voluntarily buy.   Such innovation means that the Lucas Critique is key here. One will over-estimate future damage caused by climate change using recent estimates of the "climate damage function".  The Autstrian critique of empirical economics is correct in this case.


My Bottom Line

For 15 years, I have argued that capitalism caused climate change (the GHG Engel Curve associated with fossil fuel consumption) and capitalism will solve the climate change challenge through fueling innovation and accelerating our adaptation capacity.    The old generation of Uchicago economists think alike.  Here is 2012 video where I elaborate.  

My 2009 piece; "Urban Growth and Climate Change" fleshes this out.

I reject the view that climate shocks are global macro shocks.  They are spatial shocks (such as the Texas Freeze in February 2021).  Such place based shocks impose costs and trigger cross-elasticities (flows of capital and labor to other places).  Spatial prices adjust and a new dynamic compensating differentials equilibrium is achieved.  The set of strategies that people have to adapt at any point in time pins down these price adjustments but the strategy set is always growing.  See my 2014 lecture.

Abstract

In an urbanizing world economy featuring thousands of cities, households and firms have strong incentives to make locational investments and self protection choices to reduce their exposure to new climate change induced risks. This pursuit of self interest reduces the costs imposed by climate change. This paper develops a dynamic compensating differentials model to explore how the “menu” offered by a system of cities insures us against emerging risks. Insights from urban economics offer a series of testable hypotheses concerning the economic incidence of spatially tied climate change risk.


UPDATE

One interpretation of John's blog post is that climate change mitigation should not be the world's top priority right now and instead we should focus on policies that maximize economic growth.   I think that many people who are worried about climate change would claim that we can achieve both goals through embracing the "green economy".  This claim merits more research.

In my own microeconomic research on the climate change challenge, I have not emphasized policy priorities today because I believe that the political economy is such that global greenhouse gas emissions will continue to rise.  This is why I started to work on the adaptation issue.  I discuss this point at length in chapter 1 of my 2021 Yale Press book and in the 2009 piece "Urban Growth and Climate Change" linked to above.  To repeat this point, I approach the climate change issue from a Nash Equilibrium perspective;  given that emissions are rising and that the free-rider problem at the global level is only going to get worse, how do individuals and firms adapt?  















  

My "Migration" to Substack
My "Migration" to Substack
How Will Houston Adapt to the High Heat?
The New Economic Geography of WFH
Homeownership Revisited: An Economist's Perspective
Homeownership Revisited: An Economist's Perspective
Understanding the Arguments Made by Climate Change Adaptation Pessimists: Part One
Understanding the Arguments Made by Climate Change Adaptation Pessimists: Part One
The Interesting Economics Related to the Marginal Cost of Avoiding Heat Exposure
The Interesting Economics Related to the Marginal Cost of Avoiding Heat Exposure
"The Water Cooler" and Spontaneous Face to Face Interaction in a Hybrid-WFH Economy
"The Water Cooler" and Spontaneous Face to Face Interaction in a Hybrid-WFH Economy
How Will the Rise of WFH Help Us to Adapt to Climate Change?
How Will the Rise of WFH Help Us to Adapt to Climate Change?
USC Economics Faculty Hiring Since 2015
USC Economics Faculty Hiring Since 2015
The New New Geography of Jobs
The New New Geography of Jobs
Connecting the Dots: The Common Themes Between My Three Recent Books
Connecting the Dots: The Common Themes Between My Three Recent Books
The Simple Microeconomics of Adapting to Real Estate Damage Caused by Flooding
The Simple Microeconomics of Adapting to Real Estate Damage Caused by Flooding
The Role of Qualitative Data in Academic Field Experiment Research
The Role of Qualitative Data in Academic Field Experiment Research
My Growing Set of Podcasts Discussing my April 2022 Going Remote book
My Growing Set of Podcasts Discussing my April 2022 Going Remote book
Marketing My Four Amazon Economics E-Books that Sell for $1 Each
Marketing My Four Amazon Economics E-Books that Sell for $1 Each
The Consequences of Banks Pursuing a "Double Bottom Line" as the Federal Reserve Prioritizes Climate Change Risks
The Consequences of Banks Pursuing a "Double Bottom Line" as the Federal Reserve Prioritizes Climate Change Risks
Applied Game Theory and the Medium Term Reputation Gains from the Recent China-USA Trade War
Applied Game Theory and the Medium Term Reputation Gains from the Recent China-USA Trade War
How Do We Nudge "Behavioral" Decision Makers to Adapt to Emerging Climate Risks?
How Do We Nudge "Behavioral" Decision Makers to Adapt to Emerging Climate Risks?
The Economic Consequences of Youth Pessimism About Climate Risk: Lessons from Slemrod's "Savings and the Fear of Nuclear War"
The Economic Consequences of Youth Pessimism About Climate Risk: Lessons from Slemrod's "Savings and the Fear of Nuclear War"
What Insights Does Economics Offer About the Nascent Biden Administration Transport Infrastructure Investment Program?
What Insights Does Economics Offer About the Nascent Biden Administration Transport Infrastructure Investment Program?
Contrasting Adapting to Contagious Disease Risk with Adapting to Climate Change
Contrasting Adapting to Contagious Disease Risk with Adapting to Climate Change
Will the Biden Administration's Trillion Dollar Investment in Infrastructure Unlock the Potential of Post-Industrial Cities?
Infrastructure Investment Microeconomics
Infrastructure Investment Microeconomics
A Beach Haiku
Incorporating Local Public Health Dynamics into The Rosen/Roback Spatial Equilibrium Model
Incorporating Local Public Health Dynamics into The Rosen/Roback Spatial Equilibrium Model
Adverse Selection in Car Insurance Markets: What Happens When Car Sellers Offer Insurance to Good Drivers?
Adverse Selection in Car Insurance Markets: What Happens When Car Sellers Offer Insurance to Good Drivers?
Spatial Equilibrium and Haitian Immigration to the U.S
Spatial Equilibrium and Haitian Immigration to the U.S
Some Microeconomics of Extreme Heat Exposure in the United States
Some Microeconomics of Extreme Heat Exposure in the United States
Amazon's Big Data on Consumer Behavior Fuels its Entry into Urban Retailing
Amazon's Big Data on Consumer Behavior Fuels its Entry into Urban Retailing
What Does the Movie "Dirty Harry" Teach Us About Adapting to Climate Change Risk?
How Can the Insurance Industry Accelerate Climate Change Adaptation?
How Can the Insurance Industry Accelerate Climate Change Adaptation?
Ranking Academic Economics Power Couples Based on July 2021 REPEC Data
Ranking Academic Economics Power Couples Based on July 2021 REPEC Data
Academic Economist Productivity Rankings
Academic Economist Productivity Rankings
Stiglitz Versus Cochrane: What Are the Non-Market Quality of Life Impacts of Climate Change?
Stiglitz Versus Cochrane: What Are the Non-Market Quality of Life Impacts of Climate Change?
Some Microeconomics of Adapting to Wildfires in the American West Framed as a Gary Becker Problem Set Question
Some Microeconomics of Adapting to Wildfires in the American West Framed as a Gary Becker Problem Set Question
A Few Thoughts About Economic Growth as a Climate Change Adaptation Strategy
A Few Thoughts About Economic Growth as a Climate Change Adaptation Strategy
Climate Change Bets and Julian Simon versus Paul Ehrlich Again
Climate Change Bets and Julian Simon versus Paul Ehrlich Again
Cliff Winston's New Book Gaining Ground
Cliff Winston's New Book Gaining Ground
A Self Evaluation of My Two Years Directing the Johns Hopkins 21st Century Cities Initiative
A Self Evaluation of My Two Years Directing the Johns Hopkins 21st Century Cities Initiative
The Emerging New Economic Geography of the United States
The Emerging New Economic Geography of the United States
How Does Applied Microeconomic Research Accelerate Climate Change Adaptation?
How Does Applied Microeconomic Research Accelerate Climate Change Adaptation?
Do The Urban Poor Gain from Local Economic Growth?
Do The Urban Poor Gain from Local Economic Growth?
Why is Beautiful California Losing Congressional Seats? Constrained Local Housing Supply Influences National Politics
Why is Beautiful California Losing Congressional Seats? Constrained Local Housing Supply Influences National Politics
Unlocking the Potential of our "Unlocking the Potential of Post-Industrial Cities" Book
Unlocking the Potential of our "Unlocking the Potential of Post-Industrial Cities" Book
Why Climate Economics Continues to Succeed
Why Climate Economics Continues to Succeed
The Microeconomics of Enhancing the Effectiveness of Government Spending $2 Trillion Dollars on Infrastructure
The Microeconomics of Enhancing the Effectiveness of Government Spending $2 Trillion Dollars on Infrastructure
The Revealed Preference of Porch Pirates
The Revealed Preference of Porch Pirates
The Great Climate Change Race Between The Rising Threat and Our Increasing Ability to "Take a Punch"
The Great Climate Change Race Between The Rising Threat and Our Increasing Ability to "Take a Punch"
Understanding the High Cost of Military Drone Use Using a Rebound Effect Model
Understanding the High Cost of Military Drone Use Using a Rebound Effect Model
The Resurgent Consumer City by Fall 2021
Some Urban and Environmental Economics Links
Free Copies of a New Urban Economics Book: Unlocking the Potential of Post-Industrial Cities
Free Copies of a New Urban Economics Book: Unlocking the Potential of Post-Industrial Cities
Climate Change Adaptation Lessons from Freezing Texas
Unlocking the Potential of Post-Industrial Cities
The Revealed Preference Approach for Learning Microeconomics
Backwards Induction and the Demise of U.S Gas Stations in the Year 2045
Backwards Induction and the Demise of U.S Gas Stations in the Year 2045
Platform Competition and the Urban Economics of Free Speech
Platform Competition and the Urban Economics of Free Speech
How Can the Biden Administration Boost Quality of Life in Post-Industrial Cities Such as Baltimore?
How Can the Biden Administration Boost Quality of Life in Post-Industrial Cities Such as Baltimore?
Some Rust Belt Urban Economics
Free Environmental Economics Lecture Notes and Exam Questions and Access to a High Quality $8 E-book Textbook
Free Environmental Economics Lecture Notes and Exam Questions and Access to a High Quality $8 E-book Textbook
Veblen and Conspicuous Consumption Revisited: The Beneficial Role of "Invisible" Masks During a Pandemic
Veblen and Conspicuous Consumption Revisited: The Beneficial Role of "Invisible" Masks During a Pandemic
The Economics of Personal Responsibility and Human Development
The Economics of Personal Responsibility and Human Development
Will President Biden's Low Carbon Policy Efforts be Slowed Down by the Gruenspecht Effect and Slow Economic Growth?
Will President Biden's Low Carbon Policy Efforts be Slowed Down by the Gruenspecht Effect and Slow Economic Growth?
Will the Rise of Work from Home Lower Uber's Medium Term Profits?
Will the Rise of Work from Home Lower Uber's Medium Term Profits?
Some Research Notes on Using Geo-Tagged Cell Phone Data to Study Urban Economics Questions
Some Research Notes on Using Geo-Tagged Cell Phone Data to Study Urban Economics Questions
In the Year 2030, How Will Applied Microeconomists Study the Consequences of the 2020 COVID Shock?
In the Year 2030, How Will Applied Microeconomists Study the Consequences of the 2020 COVID Shock?
The Microeconomics of the Rise of Green Buildings and Climate Change Adaptation: A California Example
Using the Supply and Demand Model to Understand China's Recent Electricity and Coal Shortage
Using the Supply and Demand Model to Understand China's Recent Electricity and Coal Shortage
Competition in the Non-Profit "Green" Sector or the Industrial Organization of Non-Profits
Competition in the Non-Profit "Green" Sector or the Industrial Organization of Non-Profits
Why Does JHU's Twenty First Century Cities Initiative Focus on Urban Economic Growth?
Productivity and Climate Change Adaptation in a Spatial Economy
Productivity and Climate Change Adaptation in a Spatial Economy
Climate Change Adaptation in a Spatial Economy
Climate Change Adaptation for Urban Indian Slum Dwellers: A New Economics Research Agenda
Climate Change Adaptation for Urban Indian Slum Dwellers: A New Economics Research Agenda
My Next Steps in Working on Climate Change Adaptation Microeconomics
My Next Steps in Working on Climate Change Adaptation Microeconomics
The Lulling Effect and the Upcoming COVID19 Vaccine
The Lulling Effect and the Upcoming COVID19 Vaccine
Announcing the Formation of Climate Economics: A New Climate Resilience Consulting Firm
Pandemic Microeconomics Revisited: The Incentive Effects of Liability Shields for Contagion Risk
Pandemic Microeconomics Revisited: The Incentive Effects of Liability Shields for Contagion Risk
Clean Air as an Experience Good in Urban China
Clean Air as an Experience Good in Urban China
The Social Benefits of Social Capital in Fire Fighting Units Contrasted with the Social Cost of Social Capital in Police Units
The Social Benefits of Social Capital in Fire Fighting Units Contrasted with the Social Cost of Social Capital in Police Units
Some Thoughts on the 2019 JEL Review of My Co-Authored China Book
Some Thoughts on the 2019 JEL Review of My Co-Authored China Book
Al Pacino's Serpico and the Economics of Rotten Apples and the Missing Data Problem.
Al Pacino's Serpico and the Economics of Rotten Apples and the Missing Data Problem.
Peer Monitoring and the Urban Police: Lessons from the Microeconomics of Microfinance
Peer Monitoring and the Urban Police: Lessons from the Microeconomics of Microfinance
The Urban Economics of Big City Mayors
The Urban Economics of Big City Mayors
Private Nursing Homes, Product Differentiation and Reducing COVID-19 Contagion Risk
Private Nursing Homes, Product Differentiation and Reducing COVID-19 Contagion Risk
Will COVID-19 Reduce Smoking Rates Today and Thus Reduce Future Cancer Risk?
Will COVID-19 Reduce Smoking Rates Today and Thus Reduce Future Cancer Risk?
Real Estate Windfalls from Delaying the Fall 2020 Semester
Real Estate Windfalls from Delaying the Fall 2020 Semester
Open Source Collaboration versus Winning the Race for Receiving a COVID-19 Vaccine Patent
Open Source Collaboration versus Winning the Race for Receiving a COVID-19 Vaccine Patent
Will the COVID-19 Induced Ballooning Budget Deficit Lead to More Efficient Taxation?
Will the COVID-19 Induced Ballooning Budget Deficit Lead to More Efficient Taxation?
Larger Firms Have an Adaptation Advantage in Coping with Ongoing COVID-19 Infection Risk
Larger Firms Have an Adaptation Advantage in Coping with Ongoing COVID-19 Infection Risk
Has the Profitability of Selling Car Insurance Increased in Early 2020 Due to COVID-19?
Has the Profitability of Selling Car Insurance Increased in Early 2020 Due to COVID-19?
Will Richer People Further Increase their Social Distancing in Post COVID-19 Urban Life?
Will Richer People Further Increase their Social Distancing in Post COVID-19 Urban Life?
Low Carbon Suburban Living in 2021 in our "Post-COVID19" World
Low Carbon Suburban Living in 2021 in our "Post-COVID19" World
Do Social Networks Increase or Decrease the COVID-19 Contagion Rate?
Do Social Networks Increase or Decrease the COVID-19 Contagion Rate?
An Open Source Clinical Trial of Coronavirus Vaccines
An Open Source Clinical Trial of Coronavirus Vaccines
Measuring the Medium Run Productivity Costs of the Coronavirus Recessions
Measuring the Medium Run Productivity Costs of the Coronavirus Recessions
Will the Fear of the Coronavirus Reduce Baltimore's Long Term Murder Rate?
Will the Fear of the Coronavirus Reduce Baltimore's Long Term Murder Rate?
The Urban and Environmental Economics of Voluntary Social Distancing
The Urban and Environmental Economics of Voluntary Social Distancing
Why Did Wuhan’s Officials Respond Slowly to the Spread of the Coronavirus?
Why Did Wuhan’s Officials Respond Slowly to the Spread of the Coronavirus?
Should the City of Baltimore Issue More Municipal Debt?
Should the City of Baltimore Issue More Municipal Debt?
Does the Coronavirus Offer a Test of the Rare Disasters Asset Pricing Model?
Does the Coronavirus Offer a Test of the Rare Disasters Asset Pricing Model?
My Research and My Books
My Research and My Books
To learn more about my research click here.

To purchase one of my four books, click here.
Popular Posts
Popular Posts
Loading
Dynamic Views theme. Powered by Blogger. Report Abuse.