Sunday, April 24, 2011

A Historical Perspective on President Obama's Investment in High Speed Rail

Did you short shares of airlines when you read about the Obama Administration's investment in high speed rail?  I didn't and it seems clear that Richard White didn't either.  In this NY Times OP-ED, he makes a number of interesting points and mentions the work of one of my heroes; Robert Fogel from the University of Chicago.

To quote the article; "Yet here we are again. The Obama administration proposed a substantial subsidy, $53 billion over six years, to induce investors to take on risk that they are otherwise unwilling to assume. Such subsidies create what the economist Robert Fogel has called “hothouse capitalism”: government assumes much of the risk, while private contractors and financiers take the profit."

In the first sentence of his piece, Richard White tells  you that he is a liberal who lives in California but he goes on to say that he is happy that the deep subsidies for HSR will be cut off due to federal budget cuts.

White argues that the intellectual case for using public $ to subsidize such an infrastructure project is weak;

To quote his historical case study, "Proponents of the transcontinental railroads promised all kinds of benefits they did not deliver. They claimed that the railroads were needed to save the Union, but the Union was already saved before the first line was completed. The best Western farmlands would have been settled without the railroads; their impact on other lands was often environmentally disastrous. For three decades California commodities could move more cheaply, and virtually as quickly, by sea. The subsidies the railroads received enriched contractors and financiers, but nearly all the railroads went into receivership, some multiple times; the government rescued others."

Environmental accountants can be brought in to quantify how much greenhouse gas emissions and local air pollution will not occur if the train substitutes for driving and plane use.  This should be quantified.  Such externality reductions (if large enough) would provide a justification for government subsidies.

Professor White understands the importance of having budget priorities.  During a time of scarcity, we can't "have it all".   He writes;

"Without bond guarantees, private investors, which so far seem more prone to due diligence than the California High-Speed Rail Authority, have yet to put up money. The most astonishing thing is that even as financial problems force California to dismantle its social safety net, eviscerate its educational system, and watch its roads crumble, it has agreed on a plan for high-speed rail that demands substantial local subsidies and certainly will involve further concessions by the state to attract private investment."

So, my intuition here is that HSR advocates viewed their projects as "too big to fail" and that they assumed they could rely on the federal government for more cash injections if private financing dried up.  But, the Republicans sound pretty credible these days concerning their eagerness to cut off the sugar.

What did Professor Fogel write about the railroads?  Here is a quick overview and some references.  He studied whether railroad investments had a major impact on the development of the U.S  economy and he challenged the conventional wisdom that they did.


JIM LOOMIS said...

I think it's noteworthy that all these arguments against high-speed rail never seem to mention that these fast trains are hugely successful everywhere else in the world. Over the past 30-plus years, they have become the preferred means of transportation all over Europe and Japan and, more recently, across most of the rest of Asia. Further, if more and more Americans are opting for trains that take three hours to travel between two U.S. cities, it certainly ought to be clear to any impartial person that reducing that travel time to 90 minutes will male those trains many times more popular. It's astonishing to me that people continue to swallow the argument that "it will never work" when, in fact, it HAS worked everywhere else in the world.

Current Residence said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Kalrav Acharya said...

An interesting point that was brought up, but lacked support was the environmental impact of mass public transportation. According to a study in 2006 by the Center for Clean Air Policy, if U.S developed a full network of high speed rail for all major transit corridors, there would be a reduction in as much as 6 Billion pounds of CO2 emissions per year.
My Blog:

gysbert said...

In this time of scarcity is it prudent to not build HSR but instead spend the billions of dollars more for the airport runways and highways that will be needed? High Speed Rail is the least expensive option for increasing transportation capacity.

rgfairpurification said...

I have one of my Air Cleaner business. It control of your air quality by reducing pollutants that can contribute to headache, lung irritation and fatigue as well as more long-term conditions such as asthma, allergies and infectious diseases.

rgfairpurification said...

Indoor Air Quality are very important for people who suffer from allergies, asthma, chemical sensitivity, and other respiratory illnesses and it control dangerous viruses, bacteria, and mold spores.

Azfireandice said...

When the air conditioner is properly matched with a furnace or air handler, you get maximum efficiency and longer system life. Air conditioning and cooling efficiency is measured using a Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio. A higher SEER rating means higher energy efficiency, our Ac Repair Phoenix is one of the best service provider.

Air Conditioning Katy said...

Stay cool and save a comfortable amount of money with our quality air conditioning products. Our Air Conditioning Katy range in efficiency from 13 to 20 seer. it Provide quality installations as well as Indoor Air Quality Specialists.

kacexpress said...

Air from your home's return air ducts is blown over the heat exchanger, thus warming the air. The furnace's blower then blows the warmed air into the ductwork, which carries and disperses the warmed air throughout the home. Our Air Conditioning Service Humble business is doing good services.

Amsjettransmissions said...

Our Transmission Service Hollywood FL has expertly trained Master Technicians and qualified service and repair technicians, which was best in the field of transmission service and repair.

Trinityserviceshvac said...

It quiet lot of interesting points you have to sharing with us, it's great.
Ac repair New Orleans

Hunterheatandair said...

The best Western farmlands would have been settled without the railroads and their impact on other lands was often environmentally disastrous.
regards with
AC Service Ardmore