Monday, December 01, 2008

Why Is the New Deal Back in Style?

Paul Krugman writes "Right now there’s intense debate about how aggressive the United States government should be in its attempts to turn the economy around. Many economists, myself included, are calling for a very large fiscal expansion to keep the economy from going into free fall. Others, however, worry about the burden that large budget deficits will place on future generations."

What are the unintended consequences of a huge growth in Keynesian public spending Future inflation and new expectations of future inflations; business lobbying for bailouts and special programs for their favored projects (i.e rent seeking).

My moderate proposal here would be to return to "Rubin Economics" of balanced budget and public investment in deep R&D so that we can keep our technological edge and keep our universities great.

Historians should explain to us how the New Deal has come back in Vogue. Is it FDR's classy style?


"John Hawkins: Switching gears again here, in your opinion, what caused us to pull out of the Great Depression? Was it Roosevelt's policies, WW2...

Milton Friedman: Roosevelt's policies were very destructive. Roosevelt's policies made the depression longer and worse than it otherwise would have been. What pulled us out of the depression was the natural resilience of the economy + WW2.

You know, it's a mystery as to why people think Roosevelt's policies pulled us out of the Depression. The problem was that you had unemployed machines and unemployed people. How do you get them together by forming industrial cartels and keeping prices and wages up? That's what Roosevelt's policies in the New Deal amounted to. Essentially, increasing the role of government, enhancing the monopolistic position of labor, and creating as I said before the equivalent of price fixing cartels made things worse. So most of his policies were counterproductive."
(source http://www.rightwingnews.com/interviews/friedman.php)"


Rajan's Thoughts on rules versus Discretion

Prescott Nobel Prize and rules versus discretion redux

3 comments :

Peter said...

Friedman is great. It was the 'natural resilience of the economy,' donchaknow. Oh, and that little WWII thing helped a little bit.

Awesome.

And even if FDR's policies prolonged things, they took the edge off things as well, and kept a lot of people alive. I know conservatives don't generally approve of handouts to the non-rich, but i think there may be a place for them.

As for subsidizing rich people through 'deep R&D,' consider me not interested.

:)

Anonymous said...

Friedman was clueless about human nature, and those who believed in his incorrect prescriptions led us into the underregulated mess we're in today. Even Greenspan recently admitted that he was blind.

Are you really an economist, saying these things?

I'd love to see you debate Krugman. I'm sure you think you'd hold your own. It wouldn't be pretty.

FDR's policies were a mixed bag. But the correct decision was to TRY things. Many succeeded. In the late 30's, after recovering for a while, the economy dropped again because the gov't was too cautious and went down.

If you think balancing the budget now would help things, you're Hoover. Good luck in politics!

Matthew Tripp said...

What global biotic critcal mass life energy sustainability word abacus measures the semantic web seed?
Life energy word abacus educational infrastructure transmission measurement sociology subject index context mapping distributed computing crowdsourcing critical thinking multimedia augmented reality remembrance agent software and hardware.

torrent random repeat all 125 tracks = the art of war audiobook flash cards, 48 laws of power DaoTeChing survival psychogical maniplatin lies nextup.c + incremented playback + playspeed Buddhist podcast

like a semantic media compass use this with the wheel of Buddhist terms poster to laminate pages for a beanbag game lifehacker . com /5072354/block-posters-makes-a-large-poster-from-any-image

High school + college students! GTD-Free Sourceforge.net + torrenteye.com of audio book Getting Things Done Fast. Then: Wiki TAG = go2web20.net + green on ziipa.com Ajax mashup. Adobe Flash Player + Java update CCleaner.com + WinAudit driver update.

Augmented Reality Storypole (blueprint and specifications visualizations projector or construction specification detail video for quality control and building history workmanship history)... for site workers to maintain advanced critical thinking of children s intellectual development; on iTunesU integrates to children s curriculum for work site wireless personal audio at job sites while remembrance agent software maintains safety and work task checklist's. Or home automation critical thinking multimedia selection staff (volunteered elderly or out of work persons) select multimedia and write up sociological perspective comments for the comprehension of workers children's curriculum; so that workers can share comprehension of the child's lifestream through college and context map strengths and weakness of local environment by the child's carefully assessed cognitive skills or weakness removal OR strength utilization in alternative context practices.

SHARE delicious,spy.comspy bookmarks ID: TradeSkillsLLC view 100 per page then the web2.0 + Tactical or matthewtripp + wiki tag’s.

hex shape soundproof sleep chamber touchscreen allows people to save money by sharing one house and underground walk in cooler and non electric appliances and gardening mobility investmnt group edu SWAT4 policypitch.com

2yrtimeshare multiple input per cpu wireless touchscreens/projectorS x-10.com or exercising 1yr HRM train before enlisting, while listening to wireless headphone educational mp3 like iTunesU. saves money for investing in alternative energy Wikinomics PDF search engine

and electric bike/triketruck 4 way neighborhood watch cam DVR WiMax HDTV Wi-Fi 35 frames/s blind eye cops Logistics delivery elderly demographics meals tricycle bamboo trailer neighborhood fruit tree 10 years water footprint rain harvest nature.org climate change

rotating composter climate control 4ft coldframe uses each butter/sour cream tub once to grow 1native plant terraforming wildlife habitat 87% earth life biomass=ocean humanism. Culture of Collaboration $ panic room massage cheap laser hair removal time saved fire suppression retrofit

iTunesU PDF audiobook conversion function nextup.com get more RAM pricewatch.com. I WILL TWEAK COMP OR TUTOR OR RAKE LEAVES FOR FOOD CALL NOW. TRANSPARENCY.ORG accurate precision ADHD isn’t real ClimateChange isn’t real PSY 101

Trade all Skills freely + openly to share how to knowledge. Workplace training videos specific task skills for easier performance posted to video site or howto site. Lifehacker = 8 antispyware simultaneously